Dealer’s Choice poker nights are a fantastic way to keep your home games fresh, exciting, and full of laughter. Instead of sticking to a single variant like Texas Hold’em, each dealer gets the chance to pick the poker game for that round, leading to a mix of popular, obscure, and often wild formats. Hosting a successful Dealer’s Choice night involves more than just shuffling cards—it’s about setting the tone, ensuring fair play, and maximizing the fun for everyone at the table.
Understanding the Dealer’s Choice Format
In Dealer’s Choice, each hand is played under the rules of a different poker game selected by the dealer for that round. The dealer rotates clockwise each hand, giving every player a turn to pick their favorite game.
Popular choices might include:
-
Texas Hold’em
-
Omaha Hi or Hi-Lo
-
Seven Card Stud
-
Pineapple or Crazy Pineapple
-
Badugi
-
2-7 Triple Draw
-
Follow the Queen
-
Guts Poker
-
Spit in the Ocean
This format encourages creativity, keeps players engaged, and levels the playing field by favoring adaptability over memorized strategies.
Planning Your Dealer’s Choice Night
A well-organized event starts with good planning. Consider the following steps:
1. Set the Ground Rules
Before the cards hit the felt, establish house rules everyone agrees on. Decide on:
-
Betting structure (No-Limit, Pot-Limit, or Fixed-Limit)
-
Buy-in amount and rebuy options
-
Time limits for game selection or round duration
-
Whether wild card games are allowed
2. Choose a Balanced Game List
While freedom is fun, a curated list helps avoid confusion. Create a menu of approved games that are easy to understand and quick to play. Provide brief printed rules or a digital cheat sheet to help new players.
3. Prepare Your Space
Comfort is key. Make sure there’s enough seating, lighting, and snacks. Use quality cards and poker chips to enhance the feel of the game.
Keeping the Game Fair and Fun
Dealer’s Choice can get chaotic without good etiquette. Here are ways to maintain a great vibe:
-
Enforce time limits for game explanations and decision-making
-
Avoid overly complicated games unless everyone agrees to them
-
Encourage teaching—players should be willing to explain their chosen game
-
Promote good sportsmanship and discourage angle shooting or exploitation of rules
Rotating dealers and games gives everyone a sense of involvement, but make sure less experienced players don’t feel overwhelmed.
Encouraging Creative Game Variants
Part of the fun is discovering quirky, unconventional poker formats. Some tables allow players to invent custom games or mash up known variants. Just make sure they:
-
Are playable within a reasonable timeframe
-
Use standard hand rankings unless otherwise agreed
-
Have clear, simple rules that can be explained in under a minute
Encouraging this kind of creativity makes every game memorable.
Tips for a Smooth Dealer’s Choice Night
-
Start the night with a familiar game to warm everyone up
-
Use a rotating dealer button to track who picks next
-
Keep a whiteboard or notepad to list selected games and avoid repeats
-
Include breaks to keep energy high and minds fresh
-
Offer small prizes or trophies for fun recognition
FAQ
What if someone doesn’t know the game a dealer picks?
No problem. Either offer a quick explanation, have a cheat sheet available, or let them opt for a simpler alternative. The goal is for everyone to have fun.
Can Dealer’s Choice nights work with beginners?
Yes, especially if you stick to a curated game list and encourage teaching. It’s actually a great way for new players to explore different poker variants.
How many different games should we allow per night?
It depends on time and group size, but 5–10 different games usually keep things lively without overwhelming the table.